top of page

Choosing a Tax Preparer? Ask More Than "How Much Is My Refund?"

Writer: Michelene Desravines
Michelene Desravines
2 days ago
7 min read

Every tax season, I hear some version of the same question from people shopping for a preparer. They want to know how big their refund will be before anyone has looked at a single form. I understand why, because a refund feels like the payoff for all the paperwork, and nobody wants to leave money on the table. The trouble is that the refund number tells you almost nothing about whether your return was prepared well. If you are choosing someone to handle your taxes this year, there are better questions to ask, and the answers will protect you long after the refund hits your account.


Why the refund promise is the wrong yardstick


A refund is not a bonus or a reward for hiring a clever preparer. It is your own money coming back to you because more tax was withheld from your paychecks, or paid in estimates, than you owed for the year. The size of that refund depends mostly on your income, your withholding, and the credits and deductions you legitimately qualify for, and an honest preparer cannot change those facts. Someone who promises a large refund before seeing your documents is either guessing or planning to stretch the rules. The IRS lists promising an unusually large refund, charging fees based on the size of the refund, and refusing to sign the return as warning signs that a preparer may be after a quick profit.


Here is the part many people do not realize until it is too late. No matter who prepares your return, you are the one responsible for everything on it, according to the IRS. If a preparer inflates deductions or claims credits you do not qualify for, the IRS comes to you, not to them. The accuracy related penalty can apply when a return underreports income or claims deductions or credits you were not entitled to, and in cases of substantial understatement it equals 20% of the underpaid tax, with interest charged on the penalty as well. That big refund can turn into a bill that is larger than the refund ever was.


Start with qualifications


The first thing to confirm is that your preparer is legally allowed to do the work. Anyone paid to prepare or help prepare a federal return must have a valid preparer tax identification number, called a PTIN, and must sign the return and include that number on it. A PTIN is the minimum, though, and it does not tell you anything about training. The IRS explains that while anyone with a PTIN can prepare federal returns, tax professionals vary widely in their skills, education and expertise. That is why the credential behind the name matters.


The most important difference between credentials is something the IRS calls representation rights. Enrolled agents, CPAs, and attorneys have unlimited representation rights, which means they can represent clients on any matter before the IRS, including audits, payment and collection issues, and appeals. A preparer with a PTIN but no professional credential who does not participate in the IRS Annual Filing Season Program can prepare returns but has no authority to represent clients before the IRS. In plain terms, if you get an audit letter or a collection notice, some preparers can stand beside you and speak to the IRS on your behalf, and others cannot. You want to know which kind you are hiring before you need that help, not after.


Checking credentials takes a few minutes. The IRS keeps a free, searchable Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers that lists attorneys, CPAs, enrolled agents and Annual Filing Season Program participants by name, city, state and zip code. Here in Florida, you can also look up a CPA directly with the state. The Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation points out that CPAs in Florida must hold a professional license and advises consumers to verify that license with the department before hiring. The IRS also suggests checking a preparer's history for complaints or disciplinary actions.


Ask about experience with situations like yours


Credentials tell you a preparer passed the exams, but experience tells you whether they have handled returns that look like yours. A return for someone with one W-2 job is very different from a return for a business owner, a landlord, a retiree drawing from several accounts, or someone who moved between states during the year. Ask the preparer directly how many clients they serve with situations similar to yours. Ask what kinds of issues they commonly find for those clients and how they handle them. A good preparer will answer comfortably and specifically, and a vague answer is useful information too.


It also helps to ask how the preparer gathers information. The IRS notes that good preparers ask to see your records and receipts so they can complete the return accurately. If someone is willing to file based on a quick conversation and a few numbers you read off your phone, that is a sign they are not checking the details that protect you. A thorough intake process can feel like more work at the start. It is also the reason your return holds up if the IRS ever asks questions.


Understand the fees before you commit


Fees vary widely, and there is no single right price for tax preparation. What matters is that you understand how you are being charged and what is included. Ask whether the fee is flat, based on the forms involved, or hourly, and ask what happens if your return turns out to be more complicated than expected. Ask whether answering IRS letters after filing is included or billed separately. Getting this in writing before work begins prevents surprises for both of you.


There is one fee structure you should walk away from. The IRS advises taxpayers to avoid preparers who base their fees on a percentage of the refund. That arrangement rewards the preparer for making your refund bigger, which is exactly the pressure that leads to inflated deductions and questionable credits. The IRS also recommends making sure your refund goes directly into your own bank account and not the preparer's, and reviewing the routing and account numbers on the completed return to confirm they are correct.


Ask how your documents will be protected


Your tax documents contain nearly everything an identity thief would want, including your Social Security number, income, bank details, and the same information for your spouse and children. You have every right to ask how a preparer collects, stores and protects that information. Federal law requires tax and accounting professionals to create and maintain a Written Information Security Plan to protect client information from identity thieves and data breaches, and the IRS says that plan should be reviewed, tested and updated regularly. You can read the IRS reminder on this requirement if you want to understand what preparers are expected to do.


You do not need to be a technology expert to ask good questions here. Ask whether the preparer has a written security plan. Ask how you should send your documents, and be cautious if the only option is regular email or a text message with photos of your forms. A secure client portal is a much safer way to share files. Multifactor authentication, the extra login code sent to a phone or app, is required for tax professionals under the FTC Safeguards Rule, so it is fair to ask whether the preparer uses it to protect your data.


Make sure support continues after filing


Filing the return is not always the end of the story. IRS letters can arrive months later asking about income, verifying your identity, or proposing changes. The IRS recommends choosing a preparer who stays available after filing season in case questions come up. Some seasonal storefront operations close their doors in May, and if your preparer cannot be reached when a notice shows up, you are left to sort it out alone. Ask plainly who you should call if you receive an IRS letter in August or the following year.


This is also where representation rights come back into the picture. A preparer who can review a notice, explain what it means, and respond to the IRS for you saves you hours of stress and phone calls. Before you sign anything, take time to read the return yourself. The IRS says to always review your return before signing, ask questions about anything that looks unclear or wrong, and never sign a blank or incomplete return. If a preparer causes you financial harm through misconduct or improper practices, you can file a complaint with the IRS.


Questions to bring to your first conversation


When you sit down with a potential preparer, a short list of questions keeps the conversation focused on what matters. Each of these takes less than a minute to ask, and the answers will tell you far more than any refund estimate.


  • What credentials do you hold, and can I verify your license?

  • Do you have unlimited representation rights if I am audited or receive a collection notice?

  • How many clients do you work with whose tax situation looks like mine?

  • How do you charge, and is help with IRS letters after filing included?

  • How do I send you my documents, and how do you protect them?

  • How can I reach you after tax season ends?


Find the right fit for your situation


The right preparer is not the one who promises the biggest number. It is the one who gets your return right, protects your information, and is still there when the IRS has questions. As a Florida CPA, I work with individuals and businesses on tax preparation, tax planning, accounting and IRS resolution, so I see both sides of this, the returns done carefully from the start and the ones that need fixing later. If you are deciding who should handle your taxes this year, I would be glad to talk with you about my services and whether they are a good fit for what you need. Bring your questions, including the ones above, and we can figure out together whether working with me makes sense for you.


Comments


bottom of page